Is It Right for You?
With many otolaryngologists curious about endoscopic ear surgery, experienced EES surgeons say it’s likely worth pursuing if you already see a fair amount of ear cases and have some experience with endoscopes. But without those, it likely isn’t worth it.
Explore This Issue
May 2020Drs. Isaacson and Kutz began performing EES with the instruments they already had, but Dr. Isaacson recommended purchasing 3-millimeter-diameter endoscopes of 0 degrees and either 30 or 45 degrees, at 12 to 14 cm in length. Most centers will already have the video monitors and other equipment that’s necessary, but physicians will need to make sure they have a 3-chip camera.
Dr. Lee cautioned that EES procedures can’t be picked up instantly. “If you’ve had little to no experience using an endoscope to do any sort of otolaryngological procedure, then this wouldn’t be something you want to tackle,” he said. “Putting an endoscope in your hand doesn’t make it easier. It’s a skill set, and it can be difficult to learn how to pick it up at the beginning.”
Dr. Ashmead, just beginning to tackle EES cases after her recent training, believes the procedure is something general otolaryngologists should consider. “I think it’s always worthwhile to learn to use your current skills in a different way,” she said, “especially if it makes you feel more comfortable or more adept at procedures you’re already doing. We should be open to learning new ways of operating so we don’t get left behind.”
Thomas Collins is a freelance medical writer based in Florida.
Key Points
- There is a learning curve in technique that varies from surgeon to surgeon, and a logical progression in the types of procedures performed when beginning.
- The technique is likely worth the investment if an otolaryngologist sees a fair amount of ear cases and has endoscope experience.
Endoscopic Ear Surgery: A Tale of Two Studies
A 2019 study published in the journal Otology and Neurotology (2019;40:983-993) highlighted the dramatic increase in the use of endoscopic ear surgery among otologists. The study examined two surveys—one of 47 otologists conducted in 2010, and one of 28 otologists conducted in 2018:
- Have used endoscopic ear surgery for cholesteatoma 2010: 14.9% , 2018: 53.5%
- Have never used an endoscope in ear surgery 2010: 46.8% , 2018: 17.8%
- There is a role for the endoscope in cholesteatoma surgery 2010: 82.9% , 2018: 96%
- Have never attended an educational activity on endoscopic ear surgery 2010: 80.9% , 2018: 14.3%